Simon Jordan is reminded of the whole West Ham United, Sheffield United, Carlos Tevez and Javier Mascherano saga after Everton were ordered to fork over £35 million following a breach of Profit and Sustainability Rules.
It was ruled this week that the Toffees had broken PSR over a three-year period relating to the 2021/22 season.
A breach Burnley argued – successfully, in the end – had cost them their Premier League status four years ago.
What are you most looking forward to about the 2026/27 Championship season? 👀
New signings? Millwall clashes? Youngsters getting a chance? No VAR? Or something else? ⚒️
Burnley would finish 18th that season, two places and four points below Everton.
As a result, the Clarets have been awarded £35 million in compensation, a ruling Everton described in an official statement as setting a ‘dangerous and unworkable precedent’.
West Ham United, Jordan points out, found themselves at the centre of a similar flashpoint two decades ago.
Simon Jordan likens Everton fine to West Ham United v Sheffield United ruling
West Ham were forced to pay Sheffield United compensation of their own after breaking third-party ownership rules to bring Carlos Tevez and Javier Mascherano to Upton Park. The BBC reports that Sheffield United, who went down on the final day of 2006/07 after Tevez saved West Ham’s skin at Old Trafford, were awarded £20 million via an out-of-court settlement.
“Well, we’ve seen [this sort of ruling] before, for different reasons,” former Crystal Palace chairman Jordan tells talkSPORT.
“West Ham got sued by Sheffield United for the fielding of Tevez and Mascherano as third-party-owned players that hadn’t been declared properly. [Sheffield United] produced a private claim against them, and [the Hammers] paid out £20 million circa.”
Modern-day PSR rules were not in effect at the time of Tevez’s brief but brilliant spell in claret and blue.
Jordan feels that a system set up seemingly to protect clubs from reckless financial decisions has only widened the gap between the haves and relative have-nots of the Premier League.
“What is the purpose of PSR?” Jordan asks, a question he is not alone in voicing. “[Everton’s fine] is the byproduct of PSR.
“PSR’s purpose, in my original perception, was to stabilise football, create outcomes where there was a fairness about it, and also to create some sort of financial stability. What has it done? It’s just cemented the big clubs in the same position.
“It’s denied the Newcastles and the Aston Villas of the world an opportunity to unseat the Man Citys and Chelseas of the world because they haven’t got the turnover, and they’re not likely to get there as a result of it.
The Premier League was a wonderful, roaring success. One of the most investable propositions in the world. Inward investment has now been denied. Businesses can’t be built in the same way because they’re being controlled by some ridiculous, absurd rule called PSR.”
DISCUSS: West Ham would be better off keeping Crysencio Summerville than Jarrod Bowen… 🤔
Summerville had 19 goals & 9 assists in the 23/24 Championship season! 🔥
David Moyes says Everton verdict is ‘really disappointing’
Jordan fears that an almighty ‘can of worms’ has been opened at a time when Manchester City remain under investigation for 115 charges due to alleged financial breaches.
West Ham have their own financial issues to contend with. The club have already acknowledged that players will have to be sold this summer, with the departures of Mateus Fernandes and Crysencio Summerville particularly inevitable.
A confused, concerned David Moyes would enter the conversation after Jordan’s impassioned, anti-PSR rant.
“Obviously, the club are challenging [the ruling] at the moment, which is really important. But look, it’s really disappointing,” the Everton boss said on talkSPORT.
“I heard Simon quickly there saying, ‘I don’t know if this opens a huge can of worms with other events as well’. You know, teams who maybe don’t get promoted, for example, because the Premier League teams are having problems with PSR.
“For this to come back to us…”
Receive a digest of our best West Ham content each week direct to your mailbox
